COOKIES MAY NOT ARRIVE AS PICTURED DUE TO THE SUMMER HEAT
Misfit Mystery Box
$29.99
Not every item makes the cut, but that doesn’t mean they’re not delicious! Our Misfit Box is a mystery assortment of baked goods that didn’t meet our perfectionist standards or has been left over from previous menus. Here’s what you need to know:
- Mystery Selection: The items in your box are based on availability and may include any combination of our baked goods — such as cookies, breads, or a mix of both. For example, you might receive all cookies, all bread, or a variety of the two. You may also receive flavors or items that are no longer on our menu. We try to give you a variety of flavors, but it depends on what we have available, so you may receive all of one flavor.
- No Customization: The cookies are selected entirely at random, and specific requests cannot be accommodated.
- Allergy Notes: If you have allergies, please leave a comment when ordering, and we will do our best to avoid including nuts.
- No Refunds: These cookies are sold as-is, and refunds or exchanges will not be provided.
- Discounts: Because this is an already heavily discounted item, it is not eligible for any discounts or promotions.
Perfect for those who love surprises and sweet deals, our misfit cookies are full of flavor, even if they’re not picture-perfect!
This box sells out FAST. We only have a limited amount each month and they are usually gone less than an hour after they become available.
Allergy Information: (optional)
Quantity
Out of stock
Availability
Only limited quantities available each month. Once they are gone, we will restock them as soon as cookies become available.
Refunds and Returns
Because we only offer what we have available at the time, this item is not eligible for refunds, return, or exchange.
Reviews
I had previously ordered a gift box for someone for Christmas and they raved about the cookies so I wanted to try them myself. My Mystery Misfit box included a few Boston Cream Pie and mostly Chocolate Ginger cookies. The Boston Cream are delicious, but maybe a bit too sweet. The Chocolate Ginger, oh my! It sounded strange, but they are chewy, chocolatey, spicy. They are fantastic! This is a flavor that needs to come back around.
Order a misfit box of Keksi cookies and received them on time even with the bad storm we just received. They are the best tasting chocolate ginger cookies I ever had. Well worth the wait!!!!
I was excited that I got in on the misfit box. First time I was able to get in on the deal. Was excited to see what I would get and even though it was heavy in 2 flavors, it was 2 I never tried before. (there were a couple of another flavor also). They are yummy. My self control struggles when these cookies are in the house. I just need to forget they are in the freezer.
I finally snagged a Misfit Mystery Box after several tries... To my surprise & delight, it was mostly filled with Iced Oatmeal cookies. It so happens that oatmeal raisin cookies are one of my favorites, so these did not disappoint! MMMMMM with a glass of cold milk or a cup of hot tea!